Long-term Risk of False-Positive Screening Results and Subsequent Biopsy as a Function of Mammography Use
Abstract
Purpose: To retrospectively determine the long-term risk of false-positive mammographic assessments and to evaluate the effect of screening regularity on the risk of false-positive events.
Materials and Methods: Institutional review board approval was obtained, and informed consent was waived. Retrospective analysis was performed for the occurrence of false-positive assessments among 83 511 women who underwent 314 185 mammographic examinations from January 1, 1985, to February 19, 2002. Data were collected from a database that had been assembled prospectively. Two categories of false-positive events were examined: biopsies that did not reveal cancer and false-positive mammographic assessments. Rates of false-positive events were compared by using a χ2 analysis, and 95% confidence limits were calculated. Because comparisons of multiple pairs were considered, all P values that demonstrated statistical significance exceeded the requirement of the Bonferroni correction.
Results: While the overall rates of biopsies that did not reveal cancer and of false-positive mammographic assessments were similar to those found in other studies, most of the burden of false-positive events was borne by women who underwent intermittent screening. Long-term rates of false-positive events were lower among women who underwent regular screening than among those who underwent intermittent screening. In the 5-year group, 2.9% of women who underwent five mammographic examinations over the next 5 years had biopsy results that did not reveal cancer, whereas 4.6% of women who underwent three mammographic examinations over the next 5 years had biopsy results that did not reveal cancer. For women who underwent regular screening, the risk of undergoing biopsies that did not reveal cancer declined over time to 0.25% per year after several years of screening, a value that is lower than the risk of these events among women who did not undergo screening. The rate of false-positive mammographic assessments was also lower for women who underwent regular screening than for those who underwent intermittent screening.
Conclusion: Prompt annual attendance for mammographic screening reduces the occurrence of false-positive mammographic results.
© RSNA, 2006
References
- 1
Humphrey LL - 2
Kopans DB - 3
Smith RA - 4
Elmore JG - 5
Christiansen CL - 6
Fletcher SW - 7
Smith-Bindman R - 8
Brown ML - 9
Lidbrink E - 10
Barton MB - 11
Lampic C - 12
Gilbert FJ - 13
Callaway MP - 14
Sickles EA - 15
Burnside ES - 16
Esserman L - 17
Elmore JG - 18
Ulcickas Yood M - 19
Sabogal F - 20
Michaelson J - 21
Blanchard K - 22
Michaelson JS - 23
Schwartz LM - 24
Michaelson JS - 25
Michaelson JS - 26
Michaelson JS - 27
Michaelson JS - 28
Michaelson JS - 29
Michaelson JS - 30
Tabar L - 31
Mandelson MT